"A venal, dangerous lie"
By Arundhati Roy
|Is the NBA doing more harm than good in
trying to protect two lakh people as against the 40 million intended beneficiaries of the
Sardar Sarovar Dam? Especially since it has been technically established that water can be
delivered to the tail-end, Kutch and Saurashtra?
all thats happened, after everything thats been written and said, to be asked
this is one of the saddest, hardest things Ive had to face in a long time. It
reminds me of how small and ineffectual a dent one makes when one argues against an
article of faith, and that, unfortunately is what the Sardar Sarovar has become to some
people-a religious edifice, a deity, a god. And what a twisted, cruel god it is. Let me
just give you some bald facts.
For the last 15 years, Gujarat has allocated 80 per cent of its irrigation budget to the
- Lets get one thing straight. The drought is not the
reason for the water policies pursued by the State. It is the result of the policies they
have pursued over the last 15 years. You cant and wont be able to solve the
problem unless you understand what caused it. Contrary to what the government would like
you to believe, the drought is not a natural calamity. It is man-made. Or should I say
State-made? The drought is not due to a lack of rainfall. Saurashtra had 11 inches of
rainfall this year. Seven of the 10 talukas in Kutch had 75% of their average rainfall.
Yet the reservoirs are empty because they are silted up, and the groundwater levels have
dropped to their lowest in a 100 years because of deforestation, and the unrestricted,
mechanised exploitation of groundwater. The price for this, of course, is paid by the
poorest of the poor who have no access to either tubewells or political clout. Faced with
this scale of human misery, they suggest the drought is somehow caused by the absence of
the Sardar Sarovar Dam (and the evil NBA) and that the only solution is the dam!
Whats the implication? That other states which are also suffering a drought but
havent planned mega dams ought to conjure them up? Are we in for a rash of Sardar
Sarovar clones? According to Central Water Commission data, of Indias 3,200 Big
Dams, over 500 are in Gujarat. Dams on the Mahi and the Sabarmati (both miles closer to
Kutch and Saurashtra than the Narmada) havent solved the drought, but theyve
yielded enough cotton and sugarcane to create a glut, theyve kept the water parks
and the Pepsi-swilling, Mickey Mouse-minded tourists happy even as we speak (Hindustan
Times, April 28). But we are expected to believe that what 500 dams could not do, the
501st will-the amazing, astonishing, all-purpose Sardar Sarovar. This is a lie, a venal,
dangerous lie that uses human misery to further its own ends.
- For the last 15 years, Gujarat has allocated over 80% of its
entire irrigation budget to Sardar Sarovar. It has done this to the exclusion of other
smaller, more local, more immediate schemes. In Gujarats Eighth Plan (1992-97), out
of an irrigation budget of Rs 3,436 crore, 85%-Rs 2,900 crore-was allocated to it. In
order to justify this, it says the project will take water to Kutch and Saurashtra. That
it will provide drinking water to 40 million people. Take a closer look at the facts. For
the sake of argument, lets for a moment believe all the absurd, computerised,
boyzworld pyrotechnics, that claim the Narmada Canal will take water to Kutch and
Saurashtra. Lets overlook the sugar factories, the golf courses, water parks and
five-star hotels planned along the way. Lets believe everything they say. If you
look at the project documents, youll see, that even on paper, even if everything
were to go as planned, the command area irrigates only 1.8% of the cultivable land of
Kutch and 9% in Saurashtra. The rest of the water will go to already water-rich areas of
central Gujarat. This is the extent of the deceit and cynicism we are up against.
- When will the water reach this 1.8% of Kutch and 9% of
Saurashtra? In the year of our Lord 2025 (by which time the dam reservoir will be well on
its way to being silted up). This can be confirmed from a water resources ministry
document dated October 92, filed in the Supreme Court. (This again, if the project
is completed as scheduled, not taking into account any delays, such as the four-year SC
stay). So what is 1.8% of Kutch and 9% of Saurashtra expected to do until then? What of
the rest of the 98.2% of Kutch and 91% of Saurashtra? Should they stand around and watch
while the Sardar Sarovar soaks up the states irrigation budget, in their name, while
the water actually goes somewhere else?
- The claim that Sardar Sarovar will bring drinking water to
40 million-that figure yo-yos around for no apparent reason. It swings between 10 million
and 40 million. The fact is providing drinking water to villages was never part of the
vision of the planners. Even today, the costs arent included in the project costs.
When the World Bank commissioned the Independent Review, this was one fact that appalled
the Morse Committee. It was one among the many reasons that led to the Bank pulling out of
the project. The tenders for doing a feasibility study of the drinking water scheme for
Sardar Sarovar were invited only in 98. In 93 the Narmada Pipeline project was
proposed. It envisaged transporting drinking water from the Narmada to Kutch and
Saurashtra even without the Sardar Sarovar. The project cost was Rs 300 crore. It could
have been completed in three years. Seven years have gone by. Nothings been done.
Even the dead storage of the dam at its present height has enough water to meet the
drinking water needs of Kutch and Saurashtra. The only thing lacking is political will and
the funds being used up by the project.
- The important thing to keep in mind now, as this crisis
comes to a head, is how do we crawl out of the hole weve dug ourselves into? It is
encouraging to see, all over the media, the first signs of recognition that something is
seriously wrong with what has been happening so far. A lot of attention has been given to
the positive peoples initiatives, that have demonstrated in a small, but stubbornly
successful manner that the way out of this morass is smaller, more local, decentralised
projects. The wonderful work of the Tarun Bharat Sangh in Alwar has been recognised, and
rightly so, by the President. More power to them. In Kutch and Saurashtra there is a
movement called the well-recharging movement where thousands of wells have
been recharged. Even hardened politicians, the prime minister and the Gujarat chief
minister, have begun to talk of rainwater harvesting. This is wonderful. Perhaps the time
has come when we will see Big Dams as not the first, but the very last resort.It would
mean an end to thirst in Gujarat. It would mean a victory for the principles of democracy.
It would mean that we still have hope.
© Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is prohibited. To access
reprinting rights, please contact: firstname.lastname@example.org
Copyright Outlook 2000 AB10, SJ Enclave, New Delhi - INDIA