International Rivers Network Press Release
27th March 2000
US COMPANY SIGNS DEAL FOR NOTORIOUS INDIAN DAM
Opponents Demand That Ogden Withdraw
International Rivers Network
today wrote to New York-based Ogden
Corporation calling on the company to withdraw from a highly
controversial dam project on India's Narmada River. The letter is
endorsed by 124 organizations from 27 countries. Ogden signed a
Memorandum of Intent, Thursday, March 23, to develop the Maheshwar
Dam, as part of U.S. President Bill Clinton's state visit to India.
The 400 megawatt Maheshwar hydropower project is fiercely opposed by
the Narmada Bachao Andolan (Save the Narmada Movement), which
represents tens of thousands of local people, as well as by other
Indian and international human rights and environment groups because
of its social, environmental and economic impacts.
The Maheshwar Dam would displace more than 35,000 farmers, wage
laborers, fishers and crafts people in 61 villages and submerge about
1,100 hectares of rich agricultural land. Independent investigations
have found that resettlement planning for the project is totally
inadequate and that no land is available for resettlement as required
by law.
People affected by the dam are determined that they will never let it
be built. Over the last two years, thousands of farming families have
occupied the dam site nine times, barricaded all roads leading to the
dam for three months, and held mass demonstrations and hunger strikes
opposing the dam.
The dam's serious financial risks and the intense opposition to it
caused U.S. power utility PacifiCorp to back out of the project in
1998, and German utilities Bayernwerk and VEW Energie to pull out in
April 1999.
Electricity generated by the dam will cost four to five times more
than other electricity generated in Madhya Pradesh state and will be
prohibitively expensive for local consumers. The Madhya Pradesh
Electricity Board (MPEB), which signed last week's agreement with
Ogden Energy Group Inc. and Indian firm S. Kumars, has guaranteed the
project developers a return on equity of 16% for the next 35 years,
whether or not the expected amount of power is produced. As the MPEB
is on the verge of bankruptcy and cannot afford this annual payment
it has proposed to cut subsidized connections for the poor and
substantially increase tariffs.
The Madhya Pradesh government responded to popular opposition in 1988
by forming a Task Force Committee to review the dam. At the end of 8
months of deliberations, the Task Force submitted a report which
detailed cheaper and better power alternatives to the Maheshwar
Project
Ogden Energy is a wholly-owned unit of Ogden Corporation which has
interests in the airline services, entertainment, environmental and
energy sectors. The company has no experience with large dam
projects. Its current portfolio contains only six small hydroelectric
dams (four in the US and two in Costa Rica) with an average
generating capacity of about 20 megawatts each. S. Kumars is a
textile firm with no previous experience of dam building.
The IRN letter to Ogden Corporation CEO and President Scott Mackin
urges the company "to withdraw from Maheshwar and decline involvement
in a project which is based on the destruction of local peoples'
livelihoods." The letter continues "The undersigned organizations are
determined to support and publicize the struggle of the villagers in
the Narmada Valley. NGOs will not hesitate to inform the shareholders
and other stakeholders of Ogden Corporation about the social,
environmental, legal and financial risks of the Maheshwar project."
When news of Ogden's interest in the Maheshwar Dam was first reported
in the Indian press in late 1999, local people who face displacement
wrote to the company insisting that Ogden representatives should
visit the affected villages before deciding on their investment. In
February, 2000, nearly 300 elected representatives of the affected
area sent Ogden a resolution opposing the Project. Ogden has failed
to reply to these demands. No Ogden official has yet visited any of
the affected villages or spoken to their representatives.
Chittaroopa Palit of the Narmada Bachao Andolan says:
"In the coming months we will intensify our struggle at the state,
national and international levels. We will succeed in stopping the
destruction of this rich area."
For more information, go to www.narmada.org or
www.irn.org or contact
-
Patrick McCully, Campaigns Director, International Rivers Network,
California +1 510-848-1155 (w) +1 510-528-2930 (h) or patrick@irn.org
-
Venu Govindu, Friends of the Narmada, New Jersey +1 609-799-5907 (h)
+1 609-951-2823 (w) or venu@narmada.org
-
Heffa Schuecking, Urgewald, Germany, +49 2583 1031 or
urgewald@koeln.netsurf.de
-
Chittaroopa Palit, Narmada Bachao Andolan, Badwani, Madhya Pradesh,
+91-272 9022464 or nobigdam@bom4.vsnl.net.in
-
Shripad Dharmadhikary, Narmada Bachao Andolan, Baroda, Gujarat
+91-265-382232 (w) or nba@bnpl.com
-
Himanshu Thakkar, South Asia Network on Dams, Rivers and People, New
Delhi, +91 11 748 4654 or cwaterp@del3.vsnl.net.in
International Rivers Network (IRN) is a US-based nongovernmental
organization which supports local communities working to protect
their rivers and watersheds. IRN works to halt destructive river
development projects, and to encourage equitable and sustainable
methods of meeting needs for water, energy and flood management.
|